The Journal of Medical Law and Ethics has published a rebuttal paper written by Peter Adler, Robert S. Van Howe and Steven Svoboda responding to arguments made in early 2018 by Brian Morris (the Morris paper can be found here) against our 2016 paper in the Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics (the 2016 paper can be found here).

Our 2016 JLME paper referred to and was based on our successful debate in Charleston, South Carolina, where we left American Academy of Pediatrics Circumcision Task Force Member Michael Brady unable to respond to any of our arguments and effectively conceding our victory on the second day. (The JLME that published our original paper and the Morris response and the JMLE that published the recent rebuttal are two different but very similarly titled journals, confusingly enough!)